Rapid heart imaging technique may cut costs, boost care in developing world
30 Aug 2018
1
A newly developed rapid imaging protocol quickly and cheaply diagnosed heart ailments in patients in Peru, according to new research in Journal of the American Heart Association, the Open Access Journal of the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association.
In Peru, cardiovascular disease affects 3.2 million (16 per cent of the adult population), leading to a significant loss of well-being, estimated at 281,829 Disability Adjusted Life Years.
Current cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (CMR) usage in high income countries focuses on function, scar (fibrous tissue that replaces normal heart muscle tissue destroyed by injury or disease), perfusion, flow, mapping and angiography and delivers valuable clinical insights leading to targeted and precise treatments. However, these varied techniques make it slow (typically 45 minutes), expensive, complex and potentially out of reach for most people in the developing world.
In this study, researchers developed and tested a rapid CMR protocol using contrast dye that measured cardiac structure, function and scarring. The rapid diagnostics worked with existing infrastructure, took 18 minutes and cost $150 per patient resulting in important changes in patient care.
"Our CMR strategy was three to five times cheaper than current CMR exams in Peru," says James C Moon, MD, study lead author and professor at Barts Heart Centre, St Bartholomew's Hospital in London. "It also can be delivered two to three times faster and is easier than conventional CMR."
Researchers conducted scans on 98 Peruvian patients (average age 52, 60 per cent female). Scanning found 26 per cent had hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, 22 per cent had dilated cardiomyopathy, 15 per cent had ischemic cardiomyopathy (when cardiovascular disease or heart attack cause the disease), and uncovered 12 other pathologies including tumours, congenital heart disease, iron overload, amyloid plaques (abnormal protein deposits), genetic syndromes, inflamed vessels, clots and valve disease.
Researchers report CMR revealed an unsuspected new diagnosis in 19 per cent of patients or led to a change of treatment in 37 per cent. In 5 per cent, a change in care management was suggested but not delivered due to access barriers (cardiac surgery or device therapy).
Researchers found rapid CMR satisfied all imaging needs in 89 per cent of patients. In 7 per cent where CMR was the first imaging technique performed, no further non-invasive imaging was needed. CMR did not miss any diagnoses initially found by echocardiography, researchers said.
"Because the rapid CMR protocol was embedded in clinical care with training and education, it resulted in important and frequent patient management changes that appeared beneficial for both patients and the healthcare system," says Katia Menacho, PhD, study first author and cardiovascular science research fellow at Barts Heart Centre, St. Bartholomew's Hospital in London. "Lack of resources is not a justification for the absence of key diagnostic tests in the developing world."
In an accompanying editorial, Christopher M. Kramer, M.D., University of Virginia Health System in Charlottesville notes, "To make this proof-of-principle study a reality in much of the developing world, imagers will need to be trained at sites with appropriate scanner technology. Only in this way will an abbreviated protocol for evaluation of cardiomyopathies be implemented. This is an exciting time for the potential of broadening the impact of CMR throughout the developing world."
