Reliance Jio Infocomm has asked the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India to "impose highest penalty" on Bharti Airtel, accusing it of grossly exaggerating the value of data in a promotional offer and giving misleading tariff ads.
Jio has written to the telecom regulator alleging that where the advertisements issued by Airtel for prepaid and postpaid tariff packs are concerned, the unlimited calls and free data being offered by Airtel is in "gross violation of extant telecommunication laws".
Jio has further charged Airtel with misrepresenting the benefits as free unlimited calls without indicating the applicability of Fair Usage Policy (FUP).
It alleged that the free calls under Airtel's Special Tariff Voucher 345 were not really unlimited as Airtel has implemented a FUP of 300 minutes / day or 1,200 minutes / week, post which all calls are chargeable.
"Therefore, these prepaid packs do not provide unlimited free calling to customers. This fact is not discernable from the advertisements of Airtel and neither does Airtel specify in the advertisements that such limitations apply or are conceived as part of the terms and conditions," Jio claimed.
It also claimed that FUP related information is provided only by call centre executives of Airtel and that too when the issue is specifically highlighted to them.
It said that this violated and was inconsistent with Trai's instructions dated 10 September 2010.
On Airtel's advertisement of 'Free data for 12 months, worth Rs 9,000' on the prepaid STV of Rs345, Jio alleged that the data benefits were available only on paying Rs345 and therefore could not be termed free.
"Further, post expiry of the data benefits in the pack, the subscriber is charged at pay-as-you-go rates, therefore, the free data claims are grossly misleading," it said.
Arguing that the value of 3GB data (at the rate of Rs450 a month) would work out to only Rs5,400 over 12 months, Jio said that the benefits are therefore "much lower" than Airtel's claim of Rs9,000.
Jio has also accused Airtel of arbitrary discrimination between subscribers of same class, saying that offer (free data for 12 months) can be availed only by subscribers with new 4G handsets, that is 4G handsets that have previously not been used on Airtel's network.
This "arbitrary classification" by Airtel is a gross violation of the Telecom Tariff order 1999 Section IV (Transparency and Consumer Protection), Jio said.
"In view of the gross violation by Airtel of TRAI directions, instructions, tariff orders, we request the authority to take strongest action under the Act and impose highest penalty on Airtel," the letter said.