New WikiLeaks: Why was Pranab made FM, asks Clinton

18 Mar 2011

1

A day after a WikiLeaks disclosure indicated that the Congress had paid lawmakers to survive a vote of confidence in Parliament in 2008, another exposure seems to reveal that Washington closely monitors Indian political appointments - particularly those related to finance and industry.

Hillary ClintonUS secretary of state Hillary Clinton is said to have questioned Pranab Mukherjee's appointment as finance minister and also asked its embassy in Delhi why Mukherjee was preferred to Montek Singh Ahluwalia, the Planning Commssion chief.

''To which industrial or business groups is [Pranab] Mukherjee beholden? Whom will he seek to help through his policies? What are Mukherjee's priorities in the upcoming budget?

''Why was Mukherjee chosen for the finance portfolio over Montek Singh Ahluwalia? How do Mukherjee and Ahluwalia get along?'' are some of the questions Clinton asked in a cable to the US Embassy in Delhi in September 2009.

Clearly, at a time of continuing recession in the US, Clinton's concerns are about doing business in perhaps the world's fastest-growing economy, rather than India's social shortcomings.

Social causes such as AIDS prevention (which she and her husband support through their charitable foundation) were probably the last thing on her mind as she cabled, ''How does Ahluwalia feel about remaining in this position (vice-chairman of the Planning Commission)? Which, if any, particular agenda items will he be pushing? Does he get on well with the prime minister?''

Latest articles

Carmakers explore energy storage, but claims of major pivot and write-downs are overstated

Carmakers explore energy storage, but claims of major pivot and write-downs are overstated

Government advances Dholera semiconductor hub, but timelines and scale claims need caution

Government advances Dholera semiconductor hub, but timelines and scale claims need caution

South Korea’s AI chip push grows, but 2nm robotics claims remain premature

South Korea’s AI chip push grows, but 2nm robotics claims remain premature

India–Japan chip collaboration grows, but details around Axiro–EdgeCortix deal remain limited

India–Japan chip collaboration grows, but details around Axiro–EdgeCortix deal remain limited

Post-splashdown: What Artemis II taught us about the ‘deep space wall’

Post-splashdown: What Artemis II taught us about the ‘deep space wall’

Carmakers explore energy storage, but claims around Ford and GM pivot remain overstated

Carmakers explore energy storage, but claims around Ford and GM pivot remain overstated

Tesla’s robotics push continues, but Shanghai “Optimus mass production” claims remain unconfirmed

Tesla’s robotics push continues, but Shanghai “Optimus mass production” claims remain unconfirmed

VinFast eyes India growth, but details around VF MPV 7 launch remain unverified

VinFast eyes India growth, but details around VF MPV 7 launch remain unverified

Breaking the engine barrier: HAL and GE move forward on F414 co-production deal

Breaking the engine barrier: HAL and GE move forward on F414 co-production deal