Most economists and analysts
have called yesterday''s CRR hike (See: RBI raises CRR by 50 basis points to 7.5
per cent, other rates steady) as''more hawkish than expected''. Consensus opinion
favoured stable rates and reserve ratios, though some perpetual optimists were
hoping for a 25-point cut. Inflation is at the lowest in many years, as economic
growth appears to be headed for a very mild moderation. Credit growth has slowed
down, which in turn has thrown demand in some sectors off-balance - but not yet
appreciably. If
the optimists based their case for a modest rate cut on the above factors, the
majority rightly argued that inflation risks still remain and there is no economy-wide
cooling-off to warrant a rate cut. There is excess liquidity all around, while
commodity and oil prices remain at record levels. Then
there is the RBI''s present day bugbear - overseas capital inflows. When SEBI spooked
the stock market with its P-Note proposals earlier this month, the RBI governor
must have been the most relieved. If successful, he would have gained the upper
hand in his until-now losing battle against a strengthening rupee. But
that was not to be. As stock prices tanked, SEBI and the finance ministry went
on an overdrive to limit the damage. While SEBI stuck to its proposals on P-Notes,
it eased market fears by making it easer for foreign funds to come in after registrations.
Markets quickly saw through the pussyfooted attempts to block the ''wall of liquidity''
rushing into emerging markets. So they went back to their exuberant ways with
a vengeance, without even pausing to celebrate the coronation of Mukesh Ambani
as the richest corporate czar in the world. Governor
Reddy is once again a much-worried man. He cannot hike rates now when some sectors
of the economy are going through a demand slowdown. More significantly, it will
hurt the already miserable exporters even more, unless the government is willing
to subsidise them even more. So, he decided to use the only other weapon in his
armoury - the CRR. Will
the 50-point hike in CRR solve the governor''s problems? Unlikely. The ''emerging-market
decoupling'' theory is now well accepted and that would mean sustained inflows
into Indian stock markets. Of course there will be bumps on the way but, given
the incredible momentum it has now, the surge may have more to go. Yes, valuations
are clearly unsustainable and will definitely revert to more normal levels in
future. But
that future may even be many months from now, given the rising propensity of central
bankers the world over to prop-up asset prices through benevolent rate cuts and
heavy liquidity infusions. It will take some kind of a disaster in the financial
markets or a dramatic and sudden decline of US or Chinese economic growth to prick
this bubble. But,
it is unlikely that the RBI will be comfortable enough any time soon to lower
interest rates as some investors had hoped for. Though the better than expected
farm output has helped, inflation is kept artificially low through the government''s
unwillingness to increase retail fuel prices. Don''t expect this to change as we
move closer to a general election. Electoral compulsions would also mean government
spending will rise and add to domestic liquidity and inflation pressures. Any
worsening of the fiscal situation, which is now propped up by higher revenue receipts
and not by improved expenditure management as claimed by the government, will
make life more difficult for the RBI in the event of further troubles in global
financial markets. Of
course, the RBI will be more than willing to cut rates if there is a crisis of
some sorts, as it has become the favoured response among all central banks. Governor
Reddy was quite emphatic yesterday when he said we should follow the example set
by monetary authorities of other countries and respond with liberal measures in
the event of a potential crisis. It should be noted that, among all emerging economies,
India has probably the worst fiscal and current account deficits - since most
others have huge surpluses. That makes the country more vulnerable to external
shocks, as rightly pointed out by the governor. The
governor also said "we are now seeing early signs of overheating" in
the economy. This is not the first time he has talked about overheating, but has
not yet come up any suggestions on policy responses. Is this a veiled warning
on a possible flare up in price levels in future? After all, anything that is
forcefully suppressed for a long period - like the way inflation is controlled
now, has a tendency to pop up when the lid is removed. With the economy showing
no signs of an appreciable slowdown, that remains a significant risk for the RBI. Meanwhile,
banks will come under increased pressure to maintain their margins. Most of the
credit growth slowdown has happened in the more profitable retail segment. Though
corporate credit demand will remain strong as long as the investment boom continues,
businesses now have more access to other sources of funds and hence will not be
willing to pay higher interest rates. The high valuations enjoyed by banking stocks,
mostly in anticipation of foreign banks gobbling up some of the domestic lenders
when the sector opens up in 2009, may come under strain. Foreign banks have been
salivating at the huge domestic market potential for a long time, but will they
be willing to pay any price to get in?
|